True crime podcasts have become incredibly popular, offering gripping storytelling and in-depth journalism. But not all podcasts are created equal, especially if you're looking for content that’s respectful, redemptive, and rooted in a Christian worldview.
Whether you're folding laundry, going for a walk, or just enjoying some quiet time, these two Christian true crime podcasts combine real-life mystery with meaningful insight, without compromising your values.
🎙️ Hosted by: Paul Hastings
📌 Best For: Listeners who want true stories of faith, hope, and justice
The Compelled Podcast typically focuses on powerful Christian testimonies. But in Season 3, host Paul Hastings takes a deep dive into a decades-old mystery known as The Texas Killing Fields, where numerous unsolved murders occurred along a stretch of highway.
What makes this series different is its focus on the families affected and the people who still believe justice can be found. Each episode is steeped in compassion, perseverance, and an unwavering belief that light can shine through even the darkest cases.
Why You’ll Love It:
Based on real crimes, but handled with deep sensitivity
Emphasizes redemption and the power of prayer
Interviews with victims' families, pastors, and advocates
🎙️ Guest Contributor: Pastor Dave Miller
📌 Best For: Listeners who enjoy unsolved mysteries with moral reflection
While Unresolved is a general true crime podcast, some of its most thoughtful and faith-filled episodes come from Pastor Dave Miller, who occasionally joins to reflect on cases involving injustice, forgiveness, and grace.
These episodes don’t always tie everything up with a bow, but they encourage deep thinking and often explore how faith intersects with tragedy. Think of them as true crime... with a deeper question: What now?
Why You’ll Love It:
Thoughtful commentary from a Christian lens
Challenges the listener to look for God in broken situations
Includes calls for prayer and community awareness
There’s something powerful about listening to real stories that not only hold your attention but also lift your spirit or point you back to something greater. These podcasts manage to do both.
And remember. Whether you’re caring for your family, managing stress, or just taking a break from your busy week, your OneShare Health Membership includes tools that support your overall wellness. From Mental Health Support through Clever Health to 24/7 access to Virtual Urgent Care (Telemedicine), you’re never alone in your journey.
Looking for more ways to care for your family - body, mind, and soul?
Get a quote today and speak to a specialist who can help you find the Health Care Sharing Program that fits your life.